Buttermilk Falls Gorge and Rim Loop (Ithaca) Hiking Guide

Buttermilk Falls sits at the southern edge of the City of Ithaca, with a bus stop by the park, and its short loop packs a lot of gorge into a mile and a half. The Gorge Trail climbs beside Buttermilk Creek past pools, Pinnacle Rock and a run of waterfalls, and the Rim Trail drops back through the woods. Plan around the season, because the gorge side closes for winter.

permit requiredno dogs
Difficulty
moderate
Distance
1.6 mi
Elevation gain
505 ft
Trailhead
Ithaca
Buttermilk Falls at the foot of the gorgePinnacle Rock and water-carved poolsa 600-foot drop of Buttermilk Creek through the gorgeblue-blazed Rim Trail open all yearbus stop at the park entrance
springsummerfall

Permit: Buttermilk Falls State Park collects a $10 car fee daily from April 1 to November 30, 6 am to 6:30 pm. A season Empire Pass, which starts at $80 and costs less as a digital-only or renewal pass, covers it. Hiking needs no separate permit.

The Route

onX maps the loop at 1.57 miles with 505 feet of gain and recommends going counterclockwise: up the Gorge Trail from the main lot, across the top, and down the Rim Trail. Ithaca Trails lists the Gorge Trail at 0.65 miles and the Rim Trail at 0.82. The steepest climbing is in the opening flights of steps beyond the big falls, and onX says the grade eases once you reach the stone path higher up. The Rim Trail is blue-blazed dirt with filtered views into the gorge.

What the Gorge Holds

Buttermilk Creek drops 600 feet through this gorge on its way down the east slope of the Cayuga Valley, according to Ithaca Trails. The path passes deep pools, water-sculpted rock including Pinnacle Rock, and several waterfalls; onX puts the namesake falls at 165 feet. The park lists six trails in all, so the gorge and rim can be stretched toward Lake Treman for a longer day.

Seasonal Closure

State Parks closes the Gorge Trail each winter once temperatures drop below freezing and ice forms on the trail and gorge walls, and Ithaca Trails marks it as not open year-round. When checked on November 9, 2026, the park's page said all trails at Buttermilk Falls were open. The Rim Trail stays open all year and is listed for snowshoeing. Call the park or check its State Parks page before a late-fall or early-spring visit.

Fees, Parking and Dogs

Ithaca Trails lists lower and upper park lots, and a bus stop, Elmira at Buttermilk, near the lower entrance. The $10 car fee is collected from April 1 through November 30. Earlier State Parks listings for Buttermilk said pets on a leash with proof of inoculation are allowed but not in the swimming area or on the gorge trail; the current page gives only the statewide leash rule, which yields to posted signs. Bring a dog only for the Rim Trail.

Footing

onX warns that the stone paths are slick whenever water is on them. Ithaca Trails rates the Gorge Trail difficult despite its short length because of the steps. Go slowly on wet stone, keep to the built path, and save any swimming for the park's designated swimming area.

Hiking tips for Buttermilk Falls Gorge and Rim Loop (Ithaca)

  • Go counterclockwise so you climb the wet gorge stairs instead of descending them.
  • Take the bus from downtown and skip the parking question.
  • Confirm the Gorge Trail is open before late-fall or early-spring visits.
  • Leave dogs on the Rim Trail; they are banned from the gorge.
  • Wear shoes with real tread for the slick stone steps.

Nearby trails to explore

  • Robert H. Treman Gorge and Rim Loop
  • Cascadilla Gorge Trail
  • Taughannock Falls Gorge Trail

Hike this trail with TrailMates

Buttermilk is short enough for an after-work hike with friends, and the bus stops at the gate. Post a Buttermilk loop in TrailMates, set the meeting point in the event's group chat, and turn it into a Lake Treman extension if people want more. Download TrailMates on the App Store or Google Play.